South Warwickshire Family History Society War Memorial Transcription Project

WW1_Logo.jpeg

The Fallen Men of South Warwickshire - World War One


Surgeon Robert Traill BROTCHIE - HMS Bulwark, Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve

Killed on Active Service on Thursday 26th November 1914 aged 29

r brotchie


Military History

     
Theatre of War Campaign Medals Commonwealth War Grave or Memorial
Home 1914 Star, British War & Victory Medals Portsmouth Naval Memorial
     
Arrived in Theatre Bravery & Conduct Medals SWFHS Area Memorials
On or before 4 Aug 1914 ~ Leamington Spa All Saints Memorial
     
Action, Battle or Other Reason Died Date and Place Commissioned Other War Memorials 
Accidental Explosion at Anchor  13 Nov 1913 in R.N.V.R. (Gazette) St. Paul's School, Barnes, London
    Royal London Hospital
Place of Death Date and Place Mobilised Tarbert (Loch Fyne), Strathclyde
Thames Estuary off Sheerness  4 Aug 1914  
     

Circumstances of Death

Robert is listed as being killed on active service on 26th November 1914 when his ship, HMS Bulwark, was sunk during the accidental explosion of its ammunution. The following is a precis of the days events.

On Thursday 26 November 1914, HMS Bulwark was moored in the Medway Estuary taking on ammunition approximately between East Hoo Creek and Stoke Creek when, at 7.50am a massive explosion ripped through the vessel.  The Times later reported "The band was playing and some of the men were drilling on deck when the explosion occurred. A great sheet of flame and quantities of debris shot upwards, and the huge bulk of the vessel lifted and sank, shattered, torn, and twisted, with officers and men aboard..."

Picture Courtesy of Imperial War Museum (click to enlarge)

Boats of all kinds were launched from the nearby ships and shore to pick up survivors and the dead. Work was hampered by the amount of debris which included hammocks, furniture, boxes and hundreds of mutilated bodies. Fragments of personal items showered down in the streets of Sheerness. Initially 14 men survived the disaster, but some died later from their injuries. One of the survivors, an able seaman, had a miraculous escape. He said he was on the deck of the Bulwark when the explosion occurred. He was blown into the air, fell clear of the debris and managed to swim to wreckage and keep himself afloat until he was rescued. His injuries were slight. The CWGC database names 788 men from HMS Bulwark as having lost their lives in this explosion. Foregoing courtesy of the Western Front Association.


 
 Personal & Family History

 

Birth Date/Place Baptism Date/Place
29 Aug 1885 in Crouch End, London 6 Oct 1886 at Saint Barnabas, Islington
   
Parents Names Abode
James and Janet Catherine Brotchie "Ardenville", Eastnor Grove, Leamington Spa
   
Wife and Marriage Details Children
Theodosia Brotchie nee Horne Lindsay b 10 Jan 1912
6 Jul 1910 in Kingston on Thames  Jean & Joan (twins) b 27 May 1913        
   
Schools Colleges
St. Paul's School, London 1901-1905 The Royal London Hospital
   
Address History Employment History
1886 - 43 Hamilton Road, Islington 1901 - Scholar at St. Paul's School
1891 - 52 Hornsey Rise, Islington 1911 - Medical Student at the London Hospital
1901 - St. Paul's School, Lonsdale Road, London SW13 1912 - Physician 
1911 - 158 Askew Road, Hammersmith 1912 - Physician in Scotland             
1912 - Fairlight, Cadogan Road, Surbiton 1914 - Surgeon in Royal Naval Volunteer Reserve              
1914 - Tarbutt, Loch Fyne, Strathclyde